Milburn review exposes Britain's failure to make work pay and respect workers
John Harris argues that the crisis of young people outside work reflects a deeper collapse in decent pay and respect for employment, not simply the failings of individuals.
Britain's debate over young people who are not in education, employment or training has focused on the young themselves, but columnist John Harris argues the real problem lies in what has happened to paid work. Writing after last week's Milburn review, he contends that the central question of what a job should give people, from everyday dignity to a decent standard of living, has been largely absent from political discussion at the highest levels.
Harris draws on more than fifteen years of conversations with ordinary people and politicians, and says the same confusion keeps recurring. Those in positions of power tend to talk about work in terms of targets, benchmarks and welfare, while rarely asking whether the jobs on offer are worth doing or whether they offer security, pride or respect. In his view, this gap between policy language and everyday experience is one of the reasons the crisis has persisted.
He places the present situation within a longer history that many people have forgotten. Poorly paid and insecure jobs have always existed in the British economy, and they have often been the focus of bitter social conflict. Yet in the decades after the Second World War, the strength of trade unions and a shared social conscience built into the postwar consensus produced a labour market that now seems almost unimaginable. Harris acknowledges that this system was far from perfect, marked by restrictive practices, nepotism, the exclusion of minorities and widespread sexism.
The turning point, according to Harris, came with the long years of Labour's exile from power and the defeat of organised labour in the miners' strike. Those developments, he argues, opened the way for a wholesale reinvention of work, the consequences of which the country is only now beginning to confront. The effects, in his account, are visible in jobs that fail to provide either stability or a sense of worth.
The argument carries a clear message for policymakers. Harris suggests that without a serious renewal of work that carries respect and decent pay, efforts to reduce the number of young people outside employment are unlikely to succeed. The Milburn review, which prompted his column, has drawn attention to the scale of the problem, but Harris's contention is that its underlying cause is structural, and cannot be solved by focusing on the young people affected alone.
Source: theguardian.com
18
